St. Mary's College RFC & The Winters Cup

The Col. Winters Memorial Cup — our club's history in this long-running Junior competition, final by final.

The Col. Winters Memorial Cup began in 1963, when it was presented by UCD RFC.

The Col. Winters Cup has traditionally been a J4 XV cup competition. In more recent times, it is the cup contested by teams in Metro League Division 6 & 7.

St. Mary's College RFC have reached the Col. Winters Cup Final 7 times, winning on 6 occasions — 1963, 1978, 1989, 1990, 1996 & 2009 — and being losing finalists on 1 occasion — 1997.

6Cup wins
1Losing final
1963First win
2009Most recent

We've tried to put together information on all of our previous finals below. If anyone has any memories of winning or losing finals to share, please send them to archives@smcrfc.com and they'll be added below. For the J4s' full season-by-season record see the J4 XV Hub.

The Finals

Click any final to expand team photos, line-ups and match reports. Winning finals are marked in green.

1963 S. Tracey — beat Blackrock 3–0 Won
St. Mary's College RFC, inaugural Col. Winters Memorial Cup winners 1962-63

Inaugural winners of the Col. Winters Memorial Cup, 1962–63.
Back: J. Reddy (Manager), C. Hutton, B. Cassidy, L. Roche, P. Best, K. Ryan, B. O'Sullivan, N. Carmody (Coach), Fr. Seagrave
Centre: D. White, J. Cronin, O. Curran, A. Whelan, S. Tracey (Captain), B. Moran, N. Nagle, L. McMullen, L. Birkett
Front: S. Doyle, D. Churchward

The 3B XV emerged this season as perhaps the most illustrious in the club. Under the paternal guidance of Steve Tracey, assisted by manager John Reddy, they developed a spirit and level of fitness unsurpassed by any other team. This was clearly shown throughout an arduous cup campaign, enabling them to subdue all opposition and win the newly presented Col. Winters Memorial Cup, beating a very strong Blackrock team in the final. The name of St. Mary's is thus the first to appear on this trophy, and we congratulate Steve and his "lads" on the success that bestowed this honour on the club.

Captained by Steve Tracey, coached by Ned Carmody and managed by John Reddy, they won the Col. Winters Cup in its inaugural year — emphasising the strength-in-depth the club enjoyed. St. Mary's holds the distinction of being the first club to win the Winters Cup, one of several Leinster Branch trophies the club won in that trophy's first year of presentation.

Alan Whelan was the try scorer in the final. Forty-six years later, Steve Tracey and Alan Whelan sent their support to the 2009 J4s before they won the cup again.

(Team photo caption and season detail from the club's Centenary Book; try scorer from the 2009 final match report.)

1978 Peter Elliott — beat Palmerston 8–3 Won
St. Mary's College RFC Winters Cup winning team 1978

Peter Elliott captained the Junior Four XV to win the Winters Cup.

Still needed: 1978 winning line-up, and a fuller match report if one exists.

1989 Frank Kennedy — beat Greystones 10–3 Won
St. Mary's College RFC J4 League and Winters Cup double team 1988-89

J4 League and Winters Cup double, 1988–89.
Back: N. Hendrick (Assistant Coach), D. Mooney (Coach), P. Joyce, G. Delaney, M. Fearon, P. Murphy, P. McSharry, J. Boyle, M. O'Flaherty, C. Budds, N. O'Kelly, J. Pyne, V. O'Connor (Manager)
Front: E. Carr, R. McCabe, N. Byrne, J. Hussey (President), F. Kennedy (Captain), M. Thorne, B. McDevitt, G. Halpin

Captained by Frank Kennedy, coached by D. Mooney and managed by V. O'Connor, the J4s beat Greystones 10–3 in the Winters Cup final. This win was part of a J4 Double: they also won the J4 League, beating Old Wesley 14–3 in the league final. It was the club's first J4 League and Cup double.

(Team and officials from the photograph's caption in the James Maguire Archive; finals from the club's Centenary Book.)

Still needed: a match report for the 1989 final.

1990 Brendan Foley — beat Terenure 15–6 Won

Captained by Brendan Foley, the J4s retained the Winters Cup, beating Terenure 15–6 in the final.

View 1989–90 photo archive →

Still needed: 1990 winning line-up, match report, and a confirmed team photo.

1996 Kevin Lum — beat Old Belvedere 10–8 Won
St. Mary's College RFC J4 1996 Double - Winters Cup and J4 League winners

1995–96 winners of the J4 Leinster League and Winters Memorial Cup.
Standing: P. Jennings, R. McCormack, D. King, P. O'Kelly, D. Burke, P. McSharry, Andy Hoey, D. Jennings, D. Swift
Sitting: J. Killbride, S. Carroll, K. Lum (Captain), S. Taggart, E. McCabe, D. Woodcock

Skippered by Kevin Lum and coached by Donal Swift — with the help of Pat O'Brien and the Jennings family, Phillip and Derek — the J4s beat Old Belvedere 10–8 to win the Winters Cup and complete the League-Cup double, having already retained the J4 League with a 17–9 win over Terenure in the league final at Donnybrook on 23 April 1996. It capped a strong season across the club, with further wins for the J2s (Cup) and the J3s (League).

(Names as printed on the photograph, with the archive's corrections: "A.N. Other" is D. King and "D. McCarthy" should read D. Burke. Coaching detail and double confirmed by the club's Centenary Book; league final date from the final programme.)

Still needed: a fuller match report for the 1996 final.

1997 Lost to Blackrock Lost

St. Mary's reached the Winters Cup final in 1997, a year after winning the double, but finished as losing finalists to Blackrock. The club's honours list for 1996–97 records the J4s as "Winters Cup – Finalists".

Still needed for 1997: captain, final score, match report, and any photo. (Roll of honour confirms Blackrock as the 1997 winners.)

2009 Brian (Teddy) Moran — beat Blackrock 24–20 Won
St. Mary's College RFC Winters Cup winning team 2009

Energia Park, Donnybrook, Tuesday 5th May 2009. Captained by Brian (Teddy) Moran, the J4s beat Blackrock 24–20 — remembered ever since for the famous last-minute try-saving tackle by Chi-Yuen Hui. It capped a strong season in which the J4s also topped J4 League Pool 1 and reached the League play-offs.

Winters Cup final XV, 5 May 2009: 15 Colm Quinn, 14 Nick Cunningham, 13 Darragh O'Neill, 12 Paul Moran, 11 Chi-Yuen Hui, 10 Brian (Teddy) Moran (Captain), 9 Ross Wynne, 8 Padraig Nestor, 7 Tim Henderson, 6 Andy McCarthy, 5 Joe Doddy, 4 John Twomey, 3 Ross Kelly, 2 Eamonn Moran, 1 Alan Godfrey.
Replacements: David Carpenter, Philip Conway, Fionan Henry, Kieran Morrissey, James Nolan, Richie Pyne, Shane Levins.
Scorers: tries Nick Cunningham (2), Brian Moran, Fionan Henry; conversions Brian Moran (2).

Path to the final

Round 128.03.2009 — Wanderers 0–43 St. Mary's (Merrion Rd)
Round 208.04.2009 — St. Mary's 48–8 Monkstown (Templeville Rd)
Round 318.04.2009 — Old Wesley 19–22 St. Mary's (Ballycorus Rd)
Semi Final25.04.2009 — St. Mary's 23–14 Coolmine (Templeville Rd)
Final05.05.2009 — St. Mary's 24–20 Blackrock (Energia Park, Donnybrook)
View the full cup draw (Sportlomo) →

Match report — by Gavin Rafferty (Manager)

The J4's contested the Winters Cup Final on Tuesday night in Donnybrook against Blackrock.

Mary's were attempting to win their 6th Winters Cup (and first since 1996) and fielded an unchanged side from the semi-final win over Coolmine. Rock fielded a side containing recent firsts outhalf, Emmet Farrell (who also happens to be a former Ireland U-21, Ireland A and Leinster professional) who was playing his first J4 game of the season apparently, as well as a former European Cup winner with Ulster.

Rock were quick out of the traps and set a high tempo in the opening ten minutes. They got a foothold in the Mary's 22 and a succession of pick & go's led to them creating an overlap on the right and the winger stepped inside for the game's opening score. Farrell kicked the conversion from the touchline for a 7-0 lead. Rock kept up the pressure and forced a penalty just inside the Mary's half and Farrell again slotted the kick to give Blackrock a 10-0 lead early in the game.

Mary's adapted to the high tempo set by Rock and started to gain more territory and possession with Rock beginning to concede penalties at the breakdown, but the men in blue were unable to get points on the board by halftime and Rock still led 10-0 at the break.

From the first whistle of the second half, Mary's just got better and better with every man giving absolutely everything. A kick in behind the Rock backline caused some problems and when the ball was recycled, scrum-half Ross Wynne kicked across the park into space behind the Rock left winger who failed to deal with it and was beaten by the bounce which fell favourably for free-scoring winger Nick Cunningham to get the touchdown. Anything a former Leinster and Ireland A outhalf can do, a former Leinster U-20 and AIL prop who made his senior debut in direct opposition to Peter Clohessy, can do better and Teddy nailed the conversion from the touchline to make it 10-7.

It was the little break that Mary's needed and the balance of power in the match was shifting Mary's way with a good spell of territory and possession. This was an extremely good Rock side though and they got the ball in their own half and spread it to their winger who put a kick through into the Mary's half. After a bit of aerial ping-pong, Rock gathered a loose Mary's kick down the middle of the park and ran it back with intent. Spotting space in the far corner, they spread it wide and managed to score in the corner. Farrell again added the points for a 17-7 lead.

A lesser team might have folded after conceding having just pulled ourselves back into the game but this Mary's team is a tight unit having been together all season (and many of them for the last 3 years) with leadership in all parts of the team. Mary's came right back at Blackrock and kept them pinned in their own half.

From a scrum in the Rock 22, a planned move saw Number 8 Padraig Nestor pick from the base and pop to Teddy who crashed over for the score. Ted dusted himself down to convert and make the score 17-14 to Rock.

Mary's kept up the pressure and Rock were conceding more and more penalties at the breakdown. After a late tackle, the Rock fullback found out that having a European Cup winners medal doesn't make you immune to yellow cards and spent 10 minutes in the bin.

After a succession of phases and recycles in the Rock half, space appeared out wide and Mary's flashed it wide quickly and Nick has shown all season that he's the type of winger who just needs a glimpse of space. He gathered infield, put on the afterburners and rounded his winger to score his second try (only his 22nd of the season). Ted couldn't get the difficult conversion but Mary's had the lead, 19-17.

Very quickly after the restart, Mary's kicked down the line again. Their winger went back to gather but he was put under massive pressure by left wing Chi-Yuen Hui who tackled him and turned the ball over. Their winger grabbed him again but he offloaded to replacement Fionan Henry who ran through to score in the corner. Conversion missed but Mary's had extended their lead to 24-17.

As mentioned, this was a very good Blackrock side and they came right back at us. With only a few minutes left they got a penalty just inside the Mary's half and the Rock captain pointed at the posts and they added the points, confident that they could score a try to clinch it. 24-20 to Mary's.

Mary's had a lineout on halfway with the referee indicating that there was only a minute left. Unfortunately the throw was slightly crooked and Rock got the scrum. From there a succession of penalties against Mary's led to a further 9 minutes of play (the game can't end on a penalty to one side) with Rock hammering away at the Mary's line. Some fantastic close in tackling and general fringe defence held them at bay but finally they spread it wide and one of their backs, ignoring the overlap outside him, went for glory himself. The footage shows that he could have gone either side of winger Chi-Yuen, standing on the line, and scored but attempted instead to run through him. He's not the first opponent to make this mistake when facing Mary's diminutive left winger and all our previous opponents could have told him it was a mistake. Chi-Yuen did incredibly well to take the hit on his own terms and, as they fell over the line, to dislodge the ball from the Rock player's hands.

The referee blew the whistle and 2 years plus of hard work had come to fruition. The Rock lads were understandably gutted but their fullback got his second card of the game, this one a straight red, for lashing out with a boot at a Mary's player who had come on to congratulate his teammates.

This Rock team played very well on the night and I'm sure they'll come back again next season and hopefully overcome the 'Sunday curse' and field a J3 team as well.

The lads went up and collected their medals and then Teddy climbed the hallowed steps of Donnybrook and hoisted the Colonel J.J. Winters Memorial Cup aloft for St. Mary's.

On behalf of the team, I'd like to thank all the people who came out to support us on Tuesday night and all the through the season, especially the players' families who have always been vocal supporters and our mates Mossy and the J5's. I'd also like to thank the members of the inaugural (1963) Winters Cup winning team, especially their captain, Steve Treacy Snr. and their try scorer, Alan Whelan (now living in the US) for their words of support and encouragement over the recent weeks. It was great motivation for us. We think there's more to come from this team and look forward to building on this success next season.

Gavin Rafferty, Manager

(Line-up, scorers and report from the club's 2008–09 J4 match reports. The whole season is on the J4 XV 2008/09 page.)

Recent Winters Cup Campaigns

Season-by-season J4 progress in the Winters Cup, 2006–07 to 2025–26. Click a season for its full J4 record.

2006–07Round 1 — lost 15–17 to Millmount House
2007–08Round 2 — lost 30–31 to Old Wesley after extra time
2008–09Winners — beat Blackrock 24–20
2009–10Quarter-final — lost 26–32 to Terenure
2010–11Semi-final — lost 17–32 to MU Barnhall
2011–12Round 2 — lost 27–29 to Terenure
2012–13Round 2 — lost 3–30 to Wanderers
2013–14Round 2 — lost 6–19 to Wanderers
2014–15Round 2 — lost 5–17 to De La Salle Palmerston
2015–16Round 3 — lost 8–15 to Blackrock
2016–17Round 2 — lost 5–22 to Old Belvedere
2017–18Round 2 — lost 0–24 to Wanderers
2018–19Round 2 — lost 15–22 to Old Belvedere
2019–20 to 2020–21J4s in the O'Connor Cup (2020–21 not played: Covid-19)
2021–22Semi-final of the pre-season Winters Cup — lost 7–41 to Terenure
2022–23 to 2024–25J4s in the O'Connor Cup
2025–26Round 1 — conceded to Clontarf

Source: Leinster Rugby results archive and the club's records, as gathered for the J4 XV Hub.

Winters Cup Roll of Honour

Every winner since the competition began in 1963. St. Mary's wins highlighted.

1963St. Mary's College RFC
1964Old Belvedere
1965Blackrock
1966Lansdowne
1967Blackrock
1968Bective Rangers
1969Terenure
1970Terenure
1971Terenure
1972Palmerston (now DLSP)
1973Terenure
1974Blackrock
1975Blackrock
1976Old Wesley
1977Palmerston (now DLSP)
1978St. Mary's College RFC
1979Terenure
1980Wanderers
1981Old Belvedere
1982Old Belvedere
1983Bective Rangers
1984Old Belvedere
1985Wanderers
1986Old Belvedere
1987Greystones
1988Bective Rangers
1989St. Mary's College RFC
1990St. Mary's College RFC
1991Lansdowne
1992Terenure
1993Blackrock
1994Old Wesley
1995UCD
1996St. Mary's College RFC
1997Blackrock
1998Guinness
1999Greystones
2000Old Belvedere
2001Old Belvedere
2002Clontarf
2003Greystones
2004Wanderers
2005Wanderers
2006Terenure
2007Terenure
2008Old Belvedere
2009St. Mary's College RFC
2010Coolmine
2011MU Barnhall
2012Guinness
2013Wanderers
2014Old Belvedere
2015Terenure
2016Old Wesley
2017Old Belvedere
2018Old Belvedere
2019Old Belvedere
2020Not played (Covid)
2021Terenure
2022Old Wesley
2023Dublin University
2024Blackrock
2025Garda Westmanstown
2026Stillorgan-Rathfarnham
Summary of Wins

Most successful clubs in the competition's history.

12
Old Belvedere
10
Terenure
7
Blackrock
6
St. Mary's College RFC
5
Wanderers
4
Old Wesley
3
Bective Rangers, Greystones
2
Guinness, Lansdowne, DLSP
1
Clontarf, Coolmine, MU Barnhall, UCD, Dublin University, Stillorgan-Rathfarnham, Garda Westmanstown